使用mininet快速入门ONOS路由交换技术与原理-路由篇

上篇文章《使用mininet快速入门ONOS路由交换技术与原理-交换篇》
使用mininet搭建了一个简单的网络拓扑，并实现了同一交换机下同网段多主机的通信，其中涉及到的通信知识主要以二层mac地址通信为主。

但在芸芸网络的世界中，主机间的通信除了二层域外更多的还是纷繁复杂的三层ip路由通信。

路由协议可分为静态路由协议和动态路由协议，在动态路由协议中，根据路由协议的作用范围主要又分为IGP与EGP。
route-igp-egp

其中EGP中的BGP协议根据其强悍的设计可支撑起各数以亿记的路由条目，同是也是动态路由协议中最为复杂的一个。

本文将结合BGP路由协议，通过onos官方的一个sdnip小示例实现SDN下不同网段多主机的通信。

环境说明

linux系统主机一台(可虚拟机，笔者使用的是ubuntu)

拓扑如下：
top

拓扑说明

一个onos
6个ovs交换机
其中5台交换机各自连一个路由器，且其4台路由器上各自连接一个主机，另一台路由器与onos连通
4个主机处于不同的网段

quagga安装与操作

quagga介绍

由于后续需要模拟外部路由器，这里使用quagga进行模拟。
qugga是一个实现了常用路由协议的软件套件，在进行网络设备模拟时非常有用，其官网地址为：https://www.nongnu.org/quagga
quagga

同时它也是一个开源软件，源码源码地址为：https://github.com/Quagga/quagga

quagga安装

选择一个系统对应的安装方式进行安装，如ubuntu执行下命令直接安装即可：

sudo apt install bridge-utils
#quagga 1.2.4
sudo apt-get install quagga

可选项：

sudo cp /usr/share/doc/quagga-core/examples/zebra.conf.sample /etc/quagga/zebra.conf
sudo cp /usr/share/doc/quagga-core/examples/ospfd.conf.sample /etc/quagga/ospfd.conf
sudo cp /usr/share/doc/quagga-core/examples/zebra.conf.sample /etc/quagga/r1zebra.conf
sudo cp /usr/share/doc/quagga-core/examples/zebra.conf.sample /etc/quagga/r2zebra.conf
sudo cp /usr/share/doc/quagga-core/examples/ospfd.conf.sample /etc/quagga/r1ospfd.conf
sudo cp /usr/share/doc/quagga-core/examples/ospfd.conf.sample /etc/quagga/r2ospfd.conf

可选项：

sudo cp /usr/lib/quagga/* /lib

quagga操作

quagga提供了丰富的配置选项以支持对模拟的路由器进行相应的配置，对应的操作手册地址为：
https://www.nongnu.org/quagga/docs/quagga.html

如要查看bgp路由列表，在进入控制台后输入以下命令查看即可

telnet localhost 2605
show ip bgp

另，为了后续在mininet中可正确使用xterm命令，需要确保已安装xterm工具

sudo apt install xterm

拓扑创建

quagga仿真软件安装就绪后，接下来便可以对整个拓扑创建就可以了。

onos仍然使用docker运行，其余交换机、路由器、主机的创建创建使用自定义的mininet脚本进行创建。

onos与网桥创建

#启动onos，并映射端口(验证:访问8181web界面)
docker run -d -e TZ=Asia/Shanghai -p 6653:6653 -p 8101:8101 -p 8181:8181 --name onos onosproject/onos:2.7.0

创建docker网桥，并指定10.10.10网段

docker network create --subnet 10.10.10.0/24 --ip-range 10.10.10.0/24 --gateway 10.10.10.2 sdnip

让onos容器与docker网桥连接，并分配10.10.10.3地址(验证:主机ping通10.10.10.3)

docker network connect --ip 10.10.10.3 sdnip onos

启动openflow应用

app activate org.onosproject.openflow

定义拓扑脚本

#!/usr/bin/python3from mininet.cli import CLI
from mininet.log import setLogLevel, info, debug
from mininet.net import Mininet
from mininet.node import Host, RemoteController
from mininet.topo import TopoQUAGGA_DIR = '/usr/lib/quagga'
# Must exist and be owned by quagga user (quagga:quagga by default on Ubuntu)
# QUAGGA_RUN_DIR = '/var/run/quagga'
QUAGGA_RUN_DIR = '/tmp'
CONFIG_DIR = 'configs'class SdnIpHost(Host):def __init__(self, name, ip, route, *args, **kwargs):Host.__init__(self, name, ip=ip, *args, **kwargs)self.route = routedef config(self, **kwargs):Host.config(self, **kwargs)debug("configuring route %s" % self.route)self.cmd('ip route add default via %s' % self.route)class Router(Host):def __init__(self, name, quaggaConfFile, zebraConfFile, intfDict, *args, **kwargs):Host.__init__(self, name, *args, **kwargs)self.quaggaConfFile = quaggaConfFileself.zebraConfFile = zebraConfFileself.intfDict = intfDictdef config(self, **kwargs):Host.config(self, **kwargs)self.cmd('sysctl net.ipv4.ip_forward=1')for intf, attrs in self.intfDict.items():self.cmd('ip addr flush dev %s' % intf)if 'mac' in attrs:self.cmd('ip link set %s down' % intf)self.cmd('ip link set %s address %s' % (intf, attrs['mac']))self.cmd('ip link set %s up ' % intf)for addr in attrs['ipAddrs']:self.cmd('ip addr add %s dev %s' % (addr, intf))# self.cmd('/usr/lib/quagga/zebra -d -f %s -z %s/zebra%s.api -i %s/zebra%s.pid' % (self.cmd('zebra -d -f %s -z %s/zebra%s.api -i %s/zebra%s.pid' % (self.zebraConfFile, QUAGGA_RUN_DIR, self.name, QUAGGA_RUN_DIR, self.name))# self.cmd('/usr/lib/quagga/bgpd -d -f %s -z %s/zebra%s.api -i %s/bgpd%s.pid' % (self.cmd('bgpd -d -f %s -z %s/zebra%s.api -i %s/bgpd%s.pid' % (self.quaggaConfFile, QUAGGA_RUN_DIR, self.name, QUAGGA_RUN_DIR, self.name))def terminate(self):self.cmd("ps ax | egrep 'bgpd%s.pid|zebra%s.pid' | awk '{print $1}' | xargs kill" % (self.name, self.name))Host.terminate(self)class SdnIpTopo(Topo):"SDN-IP tutorial topology"def build(self):s1 = self.addSwitch('s1', dpid='00000000000000a1')s2 = self.addSwitch('s2', dpid='00000000000000a2')s3 = self.addSwitch('s3', dpid='00000000000000a3')s4 = self.addSwitch('s4', dpid='00000000000000a4')s5 = self.addSwitch('s5', dpid='00000000000000a5')s6 = self.addSwitch('s6', dpid='00000000000000a6')zebraConf = '%s/zebra.conf' % CONFIG_DIR# Switches we want to attach our routers to, in the correct orderattachmentSwitches = [s1, s2, s5, s6]for i in range(1, 4 + 1):name = 'r%s' % ieth0 = {'mac': '00:00:00:00:0%s:01' % i,'ipAddrs': ['10.0.%s.1/24' % i]}eth1 = {'ipAddrs': ['192.168.%s.254/24' % i]}intfs = {'%s-eth0' % name: eth0,'%s-eth1' % name: eth1}quaggaConf = '%s/quagga%s.conf' % (CONFIG_DIR, i)router = self.addHost(name, cls=Router, quaggaConfFile=quaggaConf,zebraConfFile=zebraConf, intfDict=intfs)host = self.addHost('h%s' % i, cls=SdnIpHost,ip='192.168.%s.1/24' % i,route='192.168.%s.254' % i)self.addLink(router, attachmentSwitches[i - 1])self.addLink(router, host)# Set up the internal BGP speakerbgpEth0 = {'mac': '00:00:00:00:00:01','ipAddrs': ['10.0.1.101/24','10.0.2.101/24','10.0.3.101/24','10.0.4.101/24', ]}bgpEth1 = {'ipAddrs': ['10.10.10.1/24']}bgpIntfs = {'bgp-eth0': bgpEth0,'bgp-eth1': bgpEth1}bgp = self.addHost("bgp", cls=Router,quaggaConfFile='%s/quagga-sdn.conf' % CONFIG_DIR,zebraConfFile=zebraConf,intfDict=bgpIntfs)self.addLink(bgp, s3)# Connect BGP speaker to the root namespace so it can peer with ONOSroot = self.addHost('root', inNamespace=False, ip='10.10.10.2/24')self.addLink(root, bgp)# Wire up the switches in the topologyself.addLink(s1, s2)self.addLink(s1, s3)self.addLink(s2, s4)self.addLink(s3, s4)self.addLink(s3, s5)self.addLink(s4, s6)self.addLink(s5, s6)topos = {'sdnip': SdnIpTopo}if __name__ == '__main__':setLogLevel('debug')topo = SdnIpTopo()net = Mininet(topo=topo, controller=RemoteController)net.start()CLI(net)net.stop()info("done\n")

定义一个python3的拓扑，名为tutorial-py3.py。其中定义了所需要的交换机、主机、路由器的link关系。

bgp路由器配置文件

如上面拓扑定义python脚本所示，各bgp路由器还需要读取对应的quagga配置文件，其中描述的对应bgp路由器的bgp配置信息。

quagga1.conf

! BGP configuration for r1
!
hostname r1
password sdnip
!
router bgp 65001bgp router-id 10.0.1.1timers bgp 3 9neighbor 10.0.1.101 remote-as 65000neighbor 10.0.1.101 ebgp-multihopneighbor 10.0.1.101 timers connect 5neighbor 10.0.1.101 advertisement-interval 5network 192.168.1.0/24
!
log stdout

quagga2.conf

! BGP configuration for r2
!
hostname r2
password sdnip
!
router bgp 65002bgp router-id 10.0.2.1timers bgp 3 9neighbor 10.0.2.101 remote-as 65000neighbor 10.0.2.101 ebgp-multihopneighbor 10.0.2.101 timers connect 5neighbor 10.0.2.101 advertisement-interval 5network 192.168.2.0/24
!
log stdout

quagga3.conf

! BGP configuration for r3
!
hostname r3
password sdnip
!
router bgp 65003bgp router-id 10.0.3.1timers bgp 3 9neighbor 10.0.3.101 remote-as 65000neighbor 10.0.3.101 ebgp-multihopneighbor 10.0.3.101 timers connect 5neighbor 10.0.3.101 advertisement-interval 5network 192.168.3.0/24
!
log stdout

quagga4.conf

! BGP configuration for r4
!
hostname r4
password sdnip
!
router bgp 65004bgp router-id 10.0.4.1timers bgp 3 9neighbor 10.0.4.101 remote-as 65000neighbor 10.0.4.101 ebgp-multihopneighbor 10.0.4.101 timers connect 5neighbor 10.0.4.101 advertisement-interval 5!network 192.168.4.0/24
!
log stdout

注意，这里的quagga4.conf中并未并192.168.4.0/24网段进行公告

quagga-sdn.conf

!
hostname bgp
password sdnip
!
!
router bgp 65000bgp router-id 10.10.10.1timers bgp 3 9!neighbor 10.0.1.1 remote-as 65001neighbor 10.0.1.1 ebgp-multihopneighbor 10.0.1.1 timers connect 5neighbor 10.0.1.1 advertisement-interval 5!neighbor 10.0.2.1 remote-as 65002neighbor 10.0.2.1 ebgp-multihopneighbor 10.0.2.1 timers connect 5neighbor 10.0.2.1 advertisement-interval 5!neighbor 10.0.3.1 remote-as 65003neighbor 10.0.3.1 ebgp-multihopneighbor 10.0.3.1 timers connect 5neighbor 10.0.3.1 advertisement-interval 5!neighbor 10.0.4.1 remote-as 65004neighbor 10.0.4.1 ebgp-multihopneighbor 10.0.4.1 timers connect 5neighbor 10.0.4.1 advertisement-interval 5!! ONOSneighbor 10.10.10.3 remote-as 65000neighbor 10.10.10.3 port 2000neighbor 10.10.10.3 timers connect 5
!
log stdout

quagga-sdn.conf为bgp反射器那个路由器的配置，与r1-r4属于ebgp关系，与onos属于ibgp关系。

mininet模拟交换机、路由器、主机

拓扑描述脚本与quagga配置文件准备好后便可启动拓扑了

#启动mininet，连接指定控制器(验证:onos中查看设备是否上线)
sudo mn --custom tutorial-py3.py --topo sdnip --controller remote,172.17.0.2 --nolistenport

拓扑中的设备创建好后，为了能让ibgp通信正常，还需要让bgp-router与onos连通。

找到docker容器10.10.10.3对应的网桥,将root-eth0加入到其中

brctl show
#sdnip网桥中添加root-eth0(验证:bgp与onos能ping通)
sudo brctl addif br-baab72ffcdfc root-eth0

测试连通性，此时是不通的

h1 ping h2

sdn-ip应用与配置

前面的步骤仅完成了拓扑的搭建，拓扑中的节点间还是处于无法通信的状态。
如想要拓扑中的各节点进行正常通信，需要onos下发流表到交换机指导数据包的转发。

此刻sdn-ip的作用便可以发挥出来了，在sdn-ip应用中实现了bgp的协议与路由储存的基本功能，并能通过所学到的route下发对应的intent，最后下发flowRule到交换机中。细节部分此处不详细展开。

sdnip应用启动

#onos集群下需要先启动confgi
app activate org.onosproject.config
#启动sdnip应用
app activate org.onosproject.sdnip

sdnip
待sdnip应用启动后便可以使用routes命令，此时onos中的route列表仍然是空的

sdnIp应用配置

访问onos的http接口，找到network配置项注入配置信息。如访问地址为：
http://172.17.0.2:8181/onos/v1/docs/#!/network47configuration/post_network_configuration

也可使用curl进行更新，如：

curl --user onos:rocks -X POST -H “Content-Type: application/json” http://172.17.0.2:8181/onos/v1/network/configuration/ -d @/home/sdn/sdnip/configs/network-cfg.json

其中传入的配置信息内容如下：

{"ports" : {"of:00000000000000a1/1" : {"interfaces" : [{"name" : "sw1-1","ips"  : [ "10.0.1.101/24" ],"mac"  : "00:00:00:00:00:01"}]},"of:00000000000000a2/1" : {"interfaces" : [{"name" : "sw2-1","ips"  : [ "10.0.2.101/24" ],"mac"  : "00:00:00:00:00:01"}]},"of:00000000000000a5/1" : {"interfaces" : [{"name" : "sw5-1","ips"  : [ "10.0.3.101/24" ],"mac"  : "00:00:00:00:00:01"}]},"of:00000000000000a6/1" : {"interfaces" : [{"name" : "sw6-1","ips"  : [ "10.0.4.101/24" ],"mac"  : "00:00:00:00:00:01"}]}},"apps" : {"org.onosproject.router" : {"bgp" : {"bgpSpeakers" : [{"name" : "speaker1","connectPoint" : "of:00000000000000a3/1","peers" : ["10.0.1.1","10.0.2.1","10.0.3.1","10.0.4.1"]}]}}}
}

配置成功后使用interfaces和bgp-speakers命令验证一下

连通验证

当sdn-ip应用启动成功后，并且配置了对应的信息后，sdn-ip会执行一系列的操作最终会下发所学到的路由记录到交换机中
intents-s

此时再查看routes信息，发现也学到了路由记录
routes

查看flows信息也可看到由intent所下发的流表项，片段如下：

deviceId=of:00000000000000a1, flowRuleCount=17ADDED, bytes=65330, packets=470, table=0, priority=40000, selector=[ETH_TYPE:lldp], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:CONTROLLER], clearDeferred]ADDED, bytes=65330, packets=470, table=0, priority=40000, selector=[ETH_TYPE:bddp], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:CONTROLLER], clearDeferred]ADDED, bytes=84, packets=2, table=0, priority=40000, selector=[ETH_TYPE:arp], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:CONTROLLER], clearDeferred]ADDED, bytes=29699, packets=378, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:1, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:6, IPV4_SRC:10.0.1.1/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.1.101/32, TCP_DST:179], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:3]]ADDED, bytes=0, packets=0, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:1, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:1, IPV4_SRC:10.0.1.1/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.1.101/32], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:3]]ADDED, bytes=0, packets=0, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:2, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:6, IPV4_SRC:10.0.2.1/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.2.101/32, TCP_SRC:179], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:3]]ADDED, bytes=0, packets=0, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:1, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:6, IPV4_SRC:10.0.1.1/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.1.101/32, TCP_SRC:179], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:3]]ADDED, bytes=36604, packets=482, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:3, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:6, IPV4_SRC:10.0.1.101/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.1.1/32, TCP_SRC:179], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:1]]ADDED, bytes=0, packets=0, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:2, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:1, IPV4_SRC:10.0.2.1/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.2.101/32], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:3]]ADDED, bytes=33197, packets=431, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:2, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:6, IPV4_SRC:10.0.2.1/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.2.101/32, TCP_DST:179], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:3]]ADDED, bytes=0, packets=0, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:3, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:6, IPV4_SRC:10.0.1.101/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.1.1/32, TCP_DST:179], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:1]]ADDED, bytes=0, packets=0, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:3, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:1, IPV4_SRC:10.0.1.101/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.1.1/32], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:1]]ADDED, bytes=98, packets=1, table=0, priority=220, selector=[IN_PORT:1, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IPV4_DST:192.168.3.0/24], treatment=[immediate=[ETH_DST:00:00:00:00:03:01, OUTPUT:3]]ADDED, bytes=98, packets=1, table=0, priority=220, selector=[IN_PORT:3, ETH_DST:00:00:00:00:01:01], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:1]]ADDED, bytes=196, packets=2, table=0, priority=220, selector=[IN_PORT:2, ETH_DST:00:00:00:00:01:01], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:1]]ADDED, bytes=196, packets=2, table=0, priority=220, selector=[IN_PORT:1, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IPV4_DST:192.168.2.0/24], treatment=[immediate=[ETH_DST:00:00:00:00:02:01, OUTPUT:2]]ADDED, bytes=0, packets=0, table=0, priority=220, selector=[IN_PORT:3, ETH_DST:00:00:00:00:02:01], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:2]]
deviceId=of:00000000000000a2, flowRuleCount=14ADDED, bytes=65052, packets=468, table=0, priority=40000, selector=[ETH_TYPE:bddp], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:CONTROLLER], clearDeferred]ADDED, bytes=84, packets=2, table=0, priority=40000, selector=[ETH_TYPE:arp], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:CONTROLLER], clearDeferred]ADDED, bytes=65052, packets=468, table=0, priority=40000, selector=[ETH_TYPE:lldp], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:CONTROLLER], clearDeferred]ADDED, bytes=33197, packets=431, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:1, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:6, IPV4_SRC:10.0.2.1/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.2.101/32, TCP_DST:179], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:2]]ADDED, bytes=0, packets=0, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:1, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:6, IPV4_SRC:10.0.2.1/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.2.101/32, TCP_SRC:179], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:2]]ADDED, bytes=0, packets=0, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:3, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:6, IPV4_SRC:10.0.2.101/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.2.1/32, TCP_DST:179], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:1]]ADDED, bytes=0, packets=0, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:1, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:1, IPV4_SRC:10.0.2.1/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.2.101/32], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:2]]ADDED, bytes=34822, packets=455, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:3, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:6, IPV4_SRC:10.0.2.101/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.2.1/32, TCP_SRC:179], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:1]]ADDED, bytes=0, packets=0, table=0, priority=1000, selector=[IN_PORT:3, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IP_PROTO:1, IPV4_SRC:10.0.2.101/32, IPV4_DST:10.0.2.1/32], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:1]]ADDED, bytes=0, packets=0, table=0, priority=220, selector=[IN_PORT:3, ETH_DST:00:00:00:00:02:01], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:1]]ADDED, bytes=196, packets=2, table=0, priority=220, selector=[IN_PORT:1, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IPV4_DST:192.168.1.0/24], treatment=[immediate=[ETH_DST:00:00:00:00:01:01, OUTPUT:2]]ADDED, bytes=196, packets=2, table=0, priority=220, selector=[IN_PORT:2, ETH_DST:00:00:00:00:02:01], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:1]]ADDED, bytes=0, packets=0, table=0, priority=220, selector=[IN_PORT:3, ETH_DST:00:00:00:00:01:01], treatment=[immediate=[OUTPUT:2]]ADDED, bytes=0, packets=0, table=0, priority=220, selector=[IN_PORT:1, ETH_TYPE:ipv4, IPV4_DST:192.168.3.0/24], treatment=[immediate=[ETH_DST:00:00:00:00:03:01, OUTPUT:3]]
……

此时再在mininet中进行h1 ping h2便会发现可以ping通了，且ttl值也作了对应的减少
pingok

通信过程原理

sdnip可以让以上拓扑通信成功的过程内容稍微有点多，这里从onos官网中拷贝出几张有价值的图例可参考一下：
sdnip1
上图描述了BGP路由记录由routes转为intents，再由intents转为flowRule流表项的大体流程
sdnip-2
上图描述了在BGP网络中，路由传递到SDN-IP的大体过程，主要为由EBGP进行路由汇总。
sdnip-3
以上图描述了在由BGP反射器学到了EBGP的路由后，再由IBGP传递给onos应用sdn-ip的过程。

再总结一下：

通信成功的原理可以参考onos官方wiki中sdnip应用的架构描述部分，主要为在onos配置了bgp信息和interface后下发了
Single-point to single-point intents，实现了bgp各节点的通信；随后在onos学到了bgp路由信息后向交换机下发了
Multi-point to single-point intents，实现了各主机间的通信。

新增ebgp节点路由公告

上面实现了h1、h2、h3这3个主机间的互相通信，但h4还没有通，这是因为在r4路由器的bgp配置中未将192.168.4.0/24网段公告出去，也就导致onos不能通过ibgp学到r4路由器的主机路由信息。
此时想要让r4能通在r4的路由器修改配置使其生效即可。

操作如下：

xterm r4
在弹出的r4界面中登录bgp路由器cli

#login bgp router,passwd: sdnip
telnet localhost 2605

并配置如下：

r4> enable
r4# configure terminal
r4(config)# router bgp 65004
r4(config-router)# network 192.168.4.0/24
r4(config-router)# exit
r4(config)# exit
r4# exit
Connection closed by foreign host.

quagga-cli

之后再ping就可以通了
pingh4ok

最终的路由记录与intent信息如下：
routes-intents

最后再来个拓扑图回忆一下：

onos-top

参考资料

https://wiki.onosproject.org/display/ONOS/Basic+ONOS+Tutorial#BasicONOSTutorial-Introduction
https://wiki.onosproject.org/display/ONOS/SDN-IP+Architecture
quagga+mininet ospf
https://medium.com/@sreejithkj52/onos-tutorial-with-mininet-part-2-ed1b30582da0
https://wiki.onosproject.org/display/ONOS/SDN-IP+Reactive+Routing
https://wiki.onosproject.org/display/ONOS/vRouter
https://github.com/ralvarep/ONOS-SDN-IP/blob/master/scenario_1/README.md
https://wiki.onosproject.org/display/ONOS/Intent+Framework
https://wiki.onosproject.org/display/ONOS/SDN-IP+Deployment+Guidelines